FROM THE EDITOR
In this Issue
Contributors
Letters to the Editor
Write to Us
Back Issues
Index
Register

Macmillan Online Dictionary

COLUMNS
Feature
A Lekker Lexicon –
South African English

NEW! 
Focus on Collocations
Introduction to MCD
Using the Dictionary in IELTS

Boo & Hooray Words
Sell, Sell, Sell!

MED Web Watch
The Eggcorn Database
http://eggcorns.lascribe.net/

arrowBook Review
I’m Not Hanging Noodles
on Your Ears

arrowYour Questions Answered

Your questions answered

In this section of the magazine, we give you a glimpse of the questions posed to us by students and teachers alike. You may find that you’ve had the same queries yourself, or that your students keep coming up with similar questions. But if you feel that you still have a few more lexical questions that you’d like to get off your chest, follow this link and we'll get back to you!

This month the answers are provided by Michael Rundell, Editor-in-Chief of the Macmillan English Dictionary.

Your questions answered
determiners and predeterminers

I have a few questions about your use of 'determiner' and related terms:

Does MED take 'determiner' to be:

  • A main part of speech (i.e. a lexical category, e.g. noun, verb, adjective)?
  • A subdivision of a part of speech (e.g. auxiliary verb, countable noun), if so which one?
  • A syntactic function (e.g. subject, object, complement)?

Does MED take 'predeterminer' to be:

  • A main part of speech (i.e. a lexical category, e.g. noun, verb, adjective)?
  • A subdivision of a part of speech (e.g. auxiliary verb, countable noun)?
  • A syntactic function (e.g. subject, object, complement)?

Thanks for your interesting questions.

Parts-of-speech are interesting categories, and like most things in language, seem to suffer from prototype effects. It looks like there is a spectrum from 'strong' category members (dog is an obvious noun) to much 'weaker' ones (like think in 'I'll have a think about that'). And occasionally we need to re-classify: thus core gained full adjectival status when it developed from a mere noun modifier ('our core values') to acquire truly adjectival characteristics ('these developments are core to the company's future'). Also, dictionaries have always used the category adverb as a bit of a fallback for anything hard to classify.

With regard to determiners and predeterminers, I don't think there is any hierarchy here. What we tend to do with any kind of 'function word' is have a box (with a red tint in the printed version) which focuses on usage, explaining the ways in which a word like both can function as a determiner, predeterminer, or pronoun, giving examples of each use (since it's unreasonable to expect that all our users will be familiar with these terms).

This seemed to us a better idea than separating these uses into different homographs (as done in many dictionaries), when all the uses convey the same semantic information.

 

To read more questions and answers, go to the Index page.